• Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • email
Sensei MarketingSensei MarketingSensei MarketingSensei Marketing
  • HOME
  • SERVICES
    • Influence Marketing
    • Web Design & Development
    • Loyalty & Rewards Programs
    • Advocacy & Community Programs
    • Pay Per Click
    • Conversion Rate Optimization
    • Content Marketing
    • Customer Analysis Report
    • Email Marketing
    • Social Media
  • BONDAI PLATFORM
  • OUR WORK
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT

Can You Be Influential While Under the Influence?

By Sam Fiorella | influence marketing | 0 comment | 13 May, 2012 | 0

The debate around influence scoring and measurement has once again reared its ugly head with a new series of articles written in Wired Magazine, Forbes and Social Media Examiner, among others. Mark Schaefer also published a book recently titled: Return on Influence, which presents the online influence tracking service Klout.com as the future of marketing: low-cost, high-speed, influence driven, and powerful.

I’ve now had a well-documented history of highs & lows with Klout that eventually led me to declare my freedom from the self-serving, vanity-driven business and more recently, to create a public awareness campaign for those afflicted from fallout of opting out of Klout.

As many have already quipped, there are few businesses or social media-related subjects that generate the amount of hate and public debate that Klout seems to inspire. However, this post isn’t about loving or hating Klout. It poses a question to those brands who have or who are considering paying Klout for access to their top ranked “influencers”.

Can an individual influence others while they’re “under the influence” of Klout?

The business of Klout.com is monitoring the quantity of social interactions one has with others, the nature of those online interactions and predicting the impact these individuals have on their social graph. Online interactions are churned through their proprietary algorithms to produce a ranking of Klout-decreed influencers on various topics using a score of 1 to 100.

Brands then shell out top dollar to access these people and reward the elite with product trials and offers in hopes that the chosen will promote and encourage purchase of the brand’s product among those they supposedly influence.

In other words influencer marketing; a concept and tactic that pre-dates Klout and even the Internet and social media for that matter. Now, I’ve been at the enterprise marketing game for almost 20 years and so this concept of engaging influencers is not new to me, in the offline or digital space. Yet I don’t understand the current fascination and blind trust that brands are placing in Klout.

What happened to accountability?

What I do know is that before Klout and their ilk became water-cooler fodder, influencers were held to a different standard. Their selection process required more accountability. CMOs demanded empirical proof of the candidate’s influence – and in many cases actual guarantees of the impact they’d deliver.

I suspect the renewed fascination in influencer marketing – and specifically online influencer marketing – can be attributed to:

  • The public’s mass adoption of social communications and networking

  • The brand’s lack of understanding of social media nuances

  • The brand’s continuing struggle to monetize social media

  • The marketers need for quick fixes and quick results

Klout plays on these trends and promises brands they can connect them with those who will positively impact their business’s sales and profitability. If not, why would anyone pay top dollar to access the Klout-annointed?

Is that blind faith well placed?

Even if you would accept that the social concept of influence can be accurately and scientifically measured with limited or sporadic data points (and let’s face it, it can’t), please consider:

1. Klout is a game. Klout plays on the vanity of individuals through various gamification techniques, which encourages those individuals to change their social behaviours in order to receive the perceived clout and “perks” awarded to those who play the game well. The fact that the game can be, well, gamed should raise serious questions in the minds of brand marketers when considering this channel for their marketing strategy and budget.

2. Undefined Context. The context of the influence is loosely – if at all – defined. Of bigger concern, the fact that who is being influenced is even less defined. For example, the king of all influencers on Klout is Justin Beiber with a perfect game score of 100. Brands are rewarding high-scorers like him with upgrades on hotel accommodations or special privileges on airplanes. Upon receiving such a perk, the hope is that The Biebs will Tweet: “This is a great hotel, you should check it out” and his followers would flock. Given that his followers are predominately pre-teen girls, the likelihood that his advertisement will have his audience pulling out their credit cards seems unrealistic. Granted that Justin is an extreme example, the point is still relevant. Where’s the audience context that is demanded in any other form of marketing plan or budget allocation?

3. Troubled History. Their self-professed “standard in influence measurement” is based on experimental and frequently changing algorithms (anyone see the contraction here?) that have caused scores to dramatically jump or decrease over night. Just the fact that we’ve proven you can game your score would have scientists releasing their rats and refocusing on another hypothesis. Yet marketers continue to believe, or maybe it’s hope?

What I believe this all boils down to is: if the individuals that Klout is selling access to are playing the game, tweeting whenever and whatever it takes to increase their score, limiting their conversations to only those that are more influential than them…are they really influencing anyone? Can you count on those people to be honestly and genuinely influential if they’re “Under the Influence” of the Klout game?

What do you think?

Sam Fiorella – Sensei
Feed Your Community, Not Your Ego

Image Credit: The Aminated Woman

Corporate Social Planning, Customer Acquisition, Marketing, Sales & Marketing, Social Influence, social media, Social Networking

Sam Fiorella

Sam Fiorella is a Partner here at Sensei Marketing, a consulting and technology firm focused on aiding global companies grow their business value through improved customer experiences. Professionally, Sam has also co-authored: Influence Marketing: How To Create, Manage and Measure Brand Advocates and is a Professor of Marketing at Seneca College and an Adjunct Professor at Rutgers Center for Management Development. Sam is also the co-founder of YellowIsForHello, a not-for-profit corporation that seeks to decrease the rate of suicide among students through peer-to-peer connections.

More posts by Sam Fiorella

Related Post

  • McDonald’s Choose Risk Mitigation Over Customer Development Innovation

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    It was reported today (see here) that McDonald’s Corp voted down a proposal to assess its impact on public health, particularly childhood obesity. The proposal was brought by consumer watchdog group: Corporate Accountability International. TheRead more

  • Brand Communities – Your Sandbox or Mine?

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    Community: a term that has been given new life in our vocabulary of late. The common connotation today is a collective of enthusiastic people organized around the lifestyle, activities and/or ethos of a brand inRead more

  • The Seven Rs of Modern Day Communications

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    Each year sees a new trend in the evolution of business communications. Over the past years people have called out Unified Communications, Cloud Computing and more recently Mobility and SIP-Enabled Infrastructure. Most predictions focus onRead more

  • Where’s the Social Beef?

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    Do you ever feel like you’ve been screwed when you order a meal? The menu tantalized you with images and words that described a wonderful, sent-from-heaven meal and then when it arrives, you say “WhatRead more

  • Announcing New Book: Influence Marketing, by Sam Fiorella & Danny Brown

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    The hype around social influence has been circling around me like a cyclone for a few years now, online, in-print and in-person. I’ve been open and honest with my views on the challenges with theRead more

0 comment

Leave a Comment

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CUSTOMER ACQUISTION

Pay Per Click
Web Design & Development
Content Marketing
Web Conversion Optimization
SEO
Email Marketing

CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE

Customer Insight Analysis
Customer Experience Management
Loyalty & Rewards Program
Advocacy & Community Programs
Influence Marketing
Social Media

RECENT BLOGS

  • How to Grow Your Influencer Community Through Data
  • How Social Monitoring and Influence Marketing Can Benefit from Human-Powered AI
  • How to Identify and Use Brand Influencers Effectively
  • Why You Need Context When It Comes to Big Data and AI
  • 2020 Customer Experience Trends Not to Overlook

PARTNERSHIPS & ACCREDITATIONS

SOCIAL MEDIA

ABOUT

About
Our Work
Blog
Speaking Events & Workshops
Contact Us

ADDRESS

100 University Avenue
Suite 500
Toronto ON
Canada
M5J 1V6
Phone: 1.416.484.1400
  • HOME
  • SERVICES
    • Influence Marketing
    • Web Design & Development
    • Loyalty & Rewards Programs
    • Advocacy & Community Programs
    • Pay Per Click
    • Conversion Rate Optimization
    • Content Marketing
    • Customer Analysis Report
    • Email Marketing
    • Social Media
  • BONDAI PLATFORM
  • OUR WORK
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT
Sensei Marketing