• Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • email
Sensei MarketingSensei MarketingSensei MarketingSensei Marketing
  • HOME
  • SERVICES
    • Influence Marketing
    • Web Design & Development
    • Loyalty & Rewards Programs
    • Advocacy & Community Programs
    • Pay Per Click
    • Conversion Rate Optimization
    • Content Marketing
    • Customer Analysis Report
    • Email Marketing
    • Social Media
  • BONDAI PLATFORM
  • OUR WORK
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT

Community Management: The 90-9-1 Rule is Dead

By Sam Fiorella | Social Enterprise | 8 comments | 6 April, 2014 | 0

We’re all familiar with the 90-9-1 rule, which states that in any group of 100 people there is/are:

– 1 member that is a super active communicator, actively engaging everyone else in the group –  he/she becomes the thought leader
– 9 who are somewhat active, engaging the rest of the group occasionally
-90 who are content to simply listen or follow the 10

90-9-1.jpgThis model has been used as the basis for many sales and marketing strategies including the growing popularity of influence marketing. Applied to social media, the 1% represents those who actively produce content across multiple digital and social channels; the 9% produce and share content as time permits and the 90% are “lurkers,” those who simply read the content produced by others and rarely – if ever – respond, contribute, or share.

The top 10 percent are those whom marketers have sought to engage in social media marketing, with hopes of encouraging referrals and recommendations that will eventually get the 90 percent to act in their favor.

However, the Internet has changed the make-up of this grouping. Web 2.0 and social media, which is accessible 24/7 – and at our fingertips thanks to mobile devices – has made it simpler for a greater number of people to become “active” contributors.  In fact, it encourages us to become more active; the more active we are, the greater tools such as Google and mobile devices can help us be more productive.

Community Management: The 90-9-1 Rule is Dead

So what does this mean for the 90-9-1 rule? Is the 1 percent still a realistic number and target for marketers? With the estimated 6.7 million people posting to blogs and 12 million people blogging on social networks – not to mention the even greater number that comment and share this content – the 1 percent category certainly doesn’t seem a big enough container for active users.

Paul Schneider presented an alternative representation of this rule based on his research of online communities; he suggests that it’s more 70-20-10. 70-20-10Assuming that the entire target audience is online, more people are becoming “active” or “somewhat active” because those that were not comfortable creating content are comfortable commenting on other people’s content or sharing that content.

Those who did not see themselves as thought leaders are becoming thought leaders – or at least influencers in some form – by virtue of the content they share or comment on.

What Does This Mean for Sales and Marketing Executives?

As our social communities grow larger and larger, they become less manageable and, as a result, less effective tools for building relationships to acquire new customers or develop existing customers.

In turn, the role of active participants in the social conversation becomes that much more critical. As a result, the role of influence marketing takes on renewed importance for sales teams.

With a greater number of people creating content within our online communities, there’s a greater threat that brand messages or brand perception will be derailed by their commentary. Of course, this is also a greater opportunity for those who can engage and sway this larger group of active users to advocate on the brand’s behalf.

Business Results or More Noise?

Further, as overall community engagement grows, identifying who within the group actually drives business results vs. creating more noise becomes a greater challenge. Volume and reach of one’s social presence becomes less important; the relationships among community members and the context of their dialogue grow in importance.

At a minimum, there are greater complexities in managing online communities, identifying influencers, and deriving meaning from those engagements. This is the great paradox of social media marketing: As our communities become larger, the more important one-to-one relationships become.

If not the one-to-one relationships between your brand and your customer, certainly we should be paying attention to the one between the customers themselves.

Traditional community building, just for the sake of building community, is a fruitless exercise. Plan your community building with an analytics underpinning that monitors and measures how communications flow, who shares what information with whom, and the net effect of those communications on customer lifetime value.

Only then can online communities be considered effective customer acquisition or customer development tools. The larger the”active” and “somewhat active” group becomes, the more important strategy and analytic tools using natural language processing will become.

Sensei Debates

Does the increase in socially active users affect a brand’s media marketing practices? Join the conversation by sharing your thoughts in the comments below.

Sam Fiorella
Feed Your Community, Not Your Ego

Community Management, Customer Acquisition, lead generation, Lead Nurturing, Social Enterprise

Sam Fiorella

Sam Fiorella is a Partner here at Sensei Marketing, a consulting and technology firm focused on aiding global companies grow their business value through improved customer experiences. Professionally, Sam has also co-authored: Influence Marketing: How To Create, Manage and Measure Brand Advocates and is a Professor of Marketing at Seneca College and an Adjunct Professor at Rutgers Center for Management Development. Sam is also the co-founder of YellowIsForHello, a not-for-profit corporation that seeks to decrease the rate of suicide among students through peer-to-peer connections.

More posts by Sam Fiorella

Related Post

  • Your Business Doesn’t Need A Facebook Page

    By Sam Fiorella | 7 comments

    I’ll start this post with the disclaimer that the title may be a little misleading. This article won’t argue that businesses can’t benefit from Facebook pages but it won’t kneel at the altar of ZuckerbergRead more

  • Managing Disruptions in Customer Acquisition Strategy with Social Relationship Software

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    In my last post for Sensei Blogs, I discussed the disruption to customer acquisition strategies that has been driven by SoLoMo or social, location, and mobile technologies. The point was that the merging of theseRead more

  • Big Budget Commercials are Poor Customer Acquisition Tools Thanks to Audience Fragmentation

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    This is not a Super Bowl commercial post; it will not rank the best/worst commercials. I made a promise to myself that I would never write another one of those; God knows there are wayRead more

  • Ben & Jerry’s: Aggressive Customer Acquisition During “Low Season”

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    You think your business has customer acquisition issues? Consider the plight of ice cream manufacturers and retailers during the winter months!  Eating ice cream – let alone buying it – during the cold winter monthsRead more

  • Where Do Conferences Make Their Money and Should Brands Invest?

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    We’re often amazed at the number of trade shows and industry conferences that occur across the country every day, and the number of new conferences that seem to pop up monthly. It seems there areRead more

8 comments

Leave a Comment

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CUSTOMER ACQUISTION

Pay Per Click
Web Design & Development
Content Marketing
Web Conversion Optimization
SEO
Email Marketing

CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE

Customer Insight Analysis
Customer Experience Management
Loyalty & Rewards Program
Advocacy & Community Programs
Influence Marketing
Social Media

RECENT BLOGS

  • How to Grow Your Influencer Community Through Data
  • How Social Monitoring and Influence Marketing Can Benefit from Human-Powered AI
  • How to Identify and Use Brand Influencers Effectively
  • Why You Need Context When It Comes to Big Data and AI
  • 2020 Customer Experience Trends Not to Overlook

PARTNERSHIPS & ACCREDITATIONS

SOCIAL MEDIA

ABOUT

About
Our Work
Blog
Speaking Events & Workshops
Contact Us

ADDRESS

100 University Avenue
Suite 500
Toronto ON
Canada
M5J 1V6
Phone: 1.416.484.1400
  • HOME
  • SERVICES
    • Influence Marketing
    • Web Design & Development
    • Loyalty & Rewards Programs
    • Advocacy & Community Programs
    • Pay Per Click
    • Conversion Rate Optimization
    • Content Marketing
    • Customer Analysis Report
    • Email Marketing
    • Social Media
  • BONDAI PLATFORM
  • OUR WORK
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT
Sensei Marketing