• Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • email
Sensei MarketingSensei MarketingSensei MarketingSensei Marketing
  • HOME
  • SERVICES
    • Influence Marketing
    • Web Design & Development
    • Loyalty & Rewards Programs
    • Advocacy & Community Programs
    • Pay Per Click
    • Conversion Rate Optimization
    • Content Marketing
    • Customer Analysis Report
    • Email Marketing
    • Social Media
  • BONDAI PLATFORM
  • OUR WORK
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT

Social Scoring, Misdirection and HR Recruiting

By Sam Fiorella | influence marketing | 0 comment | 3 June, 2012 | 0

You’re not active on Facebook? You may not be qualified to work as an Engineer.

Not Tweeting? Sorry, you can’t be hired in the Travel & Tourism industry.

No Pinterest board? You’re future as a Chef just hit a major roadblock.

To rational people such statements will seem ridiculous but in reality they’re not far from becoming factual accounts of real life job seekers if the alarming social influence measurement trend is not curbed quickly.
Gauging a person’s influence is nothing new in the marketing world and recently the socialverse has been turned on its ear with the hullabaloo over pseudo influence measurement tools such as Peerindex, Klout and Kred. Sadly, this trend is making its way into other areas of business including Human Resources. New tools such as Reppify, Identified and BranchOut are targeting HR executives with the promise of providing accurate insights into the personality and even qualifications of potential hires based on one’s social interactions.
Yes, you read that right. Analytics software is predicting your qualifications for any job type based on your social conversations. Reppify, for example is a new service that provides recruiters and HR teams an online dashboard that pulls data from LinkedIn, Facebook, Twitter, and even GitHub profiles. By scanning the job candidate’s resume and social connections it generates a “job fit score” for “reputation,” “influence,” “footprint,” and “overall candidacy .
To their credit, unlike flawed influence measurement tools like Klout.com, Reppify allows hiring managers to set some parameters with which to score candidates. However, the fact remains that your personal social engagements are being scanned to determine  your fitness for a job that most likely has nothing to do with social engagement, like a network engineer or a quality assurance analyst.

There’s Reality and then there’s Reality.

 Reppify representatives argue that their service, unlike Klout or PeerIndex, asks permission before it creates a score; however, that’s only half true. Reppify uses the email address and resume data you provide to a potential employer to match it with the public data it gathers from Google searches as well information from social network that don’t require a “friend-level connection”; in other words anything you post publicly on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Etc. So a score based on limited resources establishes an initial impression and metric about your job candidacy for HR managers who subscribe to the service.
Reppify notifies you that a potential employer generated this initial score and offers you the option to grant it access to your private social network connections and data so it may augment the initial score. If you accept, you’re granting a third party (and a potential employer) access to information you purposely didn’t share publicly. If you don’t accept, you’re essentially creating another impression of yourself. What do you have to hide?  Without sharing that additional information with the potential employer using Reppify, you’re job application is labelled with a limited score.
Some, like the CEO of Reppify argue that there’s no need to worry about such scores since they are only one tool in a list of apps and measurements used to determine your job compatibility, but from personal experience I can tell you that overworked HR teams don’t exercise such sound judgement in these decisions.  And mine is just one of many such stories. If you choose to opt-out altogether you’re required to shut off public access to all your personal information across all social sites.  The onus is on you to do so. And once again, based on personal experience with Klout, “opting out” really means they can and will reinstate you at their leisure or when it suits them.

When did we lose the importance of human insights?

When an HR manager or potential employer chooses to do some research on you as a candidate and scans your LinkedIn profile or tweets on Twitter, he is forced to exercise some judgement through the context of the information he’s reading. Software doesn’t utilize such filters and, for example, may record comments you disagree with – but are posting to share with others – as your views.
 “If I get a recruit who has only half a dozen connections on Twitter or LinkedIn, they are tainted with the belief that they are not connected and not up-to-date,” reports Human Capital Management Systems CEO Trevor Vas. Perception is reality and those perceptions are formed with lack of data as much as they are with thousands of data points. Never has this been truer than in our over-connected world where social engagement is given so much importance.
Where you have HR scoring systems based on social interactions, just like the marketing versions before them, you will see people gaming the system to mislead those they wish to impress, further poluting the metrics and diminishing the validity of the score’s claim.  And there’s no end in sight. From marketing to HR and next: Customer Service. Via Salesforce.com interface, call ­centre operators now have access to a callers’ Klout score so they can respond with the appropriate amount of deference if someone has a complaint (be extra nice if they have a high Klout score…don’t fret if they have a low score).
Again I find myself calling out businesses for their reliance on third party social scoring metrics as any form of guideline in making business decisions. The increasing volume of content being generated on the Web and through social channels (what some are calling “Big Data”) isn’t necessarily “Smart Data”. Proponents of these tools and services will claim that those who use them understand that they are limited and should be used as one of many factors in making business decisions. However, we understand the reality of tight budgets, short timelines and frankly, human nature. Where a short cut is available, the short cut is almost always used.
Am I the only one who is frightened at what the future holds as businesses continue to use pseudo-scientific analysis of people’s social media engagement (or lack thereof) as indicators of real real-life substance or value? People thought Klout was harmless yet the trend is now permeating other areas of the business with reckless abandon. I pray that this trend will turn out to be a fad we’ll all be laughing at 5 years from now, like bell-bottom pants or leg warmers. In the meantime, someone needs to give those executives relying on such tools a reality check.
Sam Fiorella – Sensei
Feed Your Community, Not Your Ego

 

Corporate Social Planning, Customer Service, influence marketing, Leadership, Social Influence, Social Selection

Sam Fiorella

Sam Fiorella is a Partner here at Sensei Marketing, a consulting and technology firm focused on aiding global companies grow their business value through improved customer experiences. Professionally, Sam has also co-authored: Influence Marketing: How To Create, Manage and Measure Brand Advocates and is a Professor of Marketing at Seneca College and an Adjunct Professor at Rutgers Center for Management Development. Sam is also the co-founder of YellowIsForHello, a not-for-profit corporation that seeks to decrease the rate of suicide among students through peer-to-peer connections.

More posts by Sam Fiorella

Related Post

  • Marketing on Tap Ep 19

    Marketing on Tap Episode 19: Social Influencers or Media Buying – Has Influence Marketing Lost Its Way?

    By Danny Brown | 0 comment

    In a recent Facebook discussion between marketers, the question was asked if social influencers are just the equivalent of traditional media buying. The point being made was, with all the paid influencer programs being usedRead more

  • Marketing on Tap Episode 6: Influencer Overkill, Brand Fatigue, and Social Influence Backlash

    By Danny Brown | Comments are Closed

    In episode six of the Marketing on Tap podcast, we ask the question – have social media influencers worn out their welcome? With recent examples of luxury resorts throwing up their arms in frustration atRead more

  • Customer Decision Making Processes and Influence Marketing

    By Sam Fiorella | 2 comments

    At the beginning of this year, Judi Samuels, working for Our Kids Media, asked me to provide an overview of influence marketing for a group of business owners who were seeking to better leverage theirRead more

  • The Business Pivot – The New Standard Operating Procedure

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    The “business pivot” is not a new dance craze doomed to live forever at  wedding receptions. Pivoting refers to a quick (and often unexpected) shift in a planned business model when the current model doesn’tRead more

  • Beware the Growth of Influencer Factories

    By Sam Fiorella | 0 comment

    If you’re in a marketing or public relations function, unless you’ve been living under a rock these past few years, you’ve seen the explosion of social scoring and influence marketing discussions and debates online. IfRead more

Leave a Comment

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CUSTOMER ACQUISTION

Pay Per Click
Web Design & Development
Content Marketing
Web Conversion Optimization
SEO
Email Marketing

CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE

Customer Insight Analysis
Customer Experience Management
Loyalty & Rewards Program
Advocacy & Community Programs
Influence Marketing
Social Media

RECENT BLOGS

  • How to Grow Your Influencer Community Through Data
  • How Social Monitoring and Influence Marketing Can Benefit from Human-Powered AI
  • How to Identify and Use Brand Influencers Effectively
  • Why You Need Context When It Comes to Big Data and AI
  • 2020 Customer Experience Trends Not to Overlook

PARTNERSHIPS & ACCREDITATIONS

SOCIAL MEDIA

ABOUT

About
Our Work
Blog
Speaking Events & Workshops
Contact Us

ADDRESS

100 University Avenue
Suite 500
Toronto ON
Canada
M5J 1V6
Phone: 1.416.484.1400
  • HOME
  • SERVICES
    • Influence Marketing
    • Web Design & Development
    • Loyalty & Rewards Programs
    • Advocacy & Community Programs
    • Pay Per Click
    • Conversion Rate Optimization
    • Content Marketing
    • Customer Analysis Report
    • Email Marketing
    • Social Media
  • BONDAI PLATFORM
  • OUR WORK
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT
Sensei Marketing